Giving people chances even though you're not super attracted to them?

I was just curious if y'all give people that are not super up your alley chances? I'm a bit of a picky person and have a hard time swiping on people in general. But more importantly, I overthink about swiping on people that are not exactly my type (out of, or even within my league).

I don't swipe on really attractive people anyway- it's too intimidating. But for the opposite case I feel like an asshole as if I'm wasting their time (which is worse than not swiping on sb tbh).

Idk I'm extremely anxious and an overthinker overall. *SIGH dating is hard :(