Anyone disagreed when Natalie (S9) got eliminated over Elise (S9)?

First time watching Hell's Kitchen, and I just finished ep. 11 of Season 9. I think Elise stays here WAY TOO LONG. Like I know Natalie messed up with the Fish Station and held the line, but Elise fucked up BAD that night too (she lied to GR about the scoring wellingtons, fucked up the New York Strip, kicked the bin,...). She should've been the one eliminated instead of Natalie (just my opinion, though; honestly, I can't stand her any longer).